This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Man Regains Speech After Brain Stimulation

Reposted from:
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/02/health/02brain.html?adxnnl=1&ref=science&adxnnlx=1186078146-Ae9FJvXwhmLYLEhaWFBJRg

A 38-year-old man who spent more than five years in a mute, barely conscious state as a result of a severe head injury is now communicating regularly with family members and recovering his ability to move after having his brain stimulated with pulses of electric current, neuroscientists are reporting.

"I still cry every time I see him, but now it's tears of joy," said the man's mother, in a conference call with reporters on Wednesday; her name was withheld, to protect the patient's privacy. "He can speak, he can watch movies without falling asleep, he can say 'Mom' and 'Pop,' and 'I love you, Mommy.' "

He eats without the assistance of a feeding tube. He has regained some movement in his arms. When he speaks, usually with only a word or two, he is engaged in the conversation. He recently recited the first 16 words of the Pledge of Allegiance.

The new report, which appears in the journal Nature, provides the first rigorous evidence that any procedure can initiate and sustain recovery in such a severely disabled person, years after the injury occurred. An estimated 100,000 to 300,000 Americans subsist in states of partial consciousness, and most are written off as beyond help.

Doctors said it was not clear how many such patients would benefit from the treatment, in which two wire electrodes are implanted deep in the brain. The procedure also raises sticky ethical questions about operating on patients who cannot give their consent, they said.

"We really see this as a first step, but it should open doors that have not been open before for patients like this," said Joseph T. Giacino, associate director of neuropsychology at the JFK Johnson Rehabilitation Institute, and the New Jersey Neuroscience Institute, in Edison. Dr. Giacino performed the study with doctors from the Weill Cornell Medical College and the Cleveland Clinic Foundation.

Other experts familiar with the case have cautioned that the study was based on a single patient, and said the procedure should be seen as experimental. The researchers, who first described the case last October at the annual meeting of the Society for Neuroscience, say they plan to look at the procedure in 11 other patients as part of a larger study.

Doctors have long used the implant surgery, known as deep brain stimulation, to treat Parkinson's disease. Over the past two decades they have also performed it on a handful of people with brain injuries, including Terri Schiavo, the Florida woman who died in 2005 after her feeding tube was removed amid a national debate over her care.

But in many of those cases, like Ms. Schiavo's, the brain was so profoundly damaged that the operation made no difference.

For the new study, researchers chose a patient who was responsive to commands, at least occasionally. After being kicked repeatedly in the head during a mugging in 1999, he was sometimes able to move his thumb in response to yes-or-no questions but do little else. He rarely opened his eyes. Yet tests showed that language circuits in the left side of his brain and running through his prefrontal cortex — the rational, conscious areas — were intact.

Brain injuries from blows to the head often sever nerve connections widely throughout the brain but can leave some circuits intact.

Surgeons at the Cleveland Clinic threaded two wires through the man's skull and into a subcortical area called the thalamus. The wires were connected to a pacemakerlike unit, implanted under the man's collarbone.

The central part of the thalamus, in particular, projects widely to areas of the brain known to play a role in supporting consciousness, said Dr. Nicholas Schiff, a neurologist at Cornell, who led the study with Dr. Giacino. "One of the key things the procedure is doing is driving neuronal firing rate in this area, which may be driving systems in the cerebral cortex involved in arousal," Dr. Schiff said.

Soon after the device was turned on, the man showed some improvements. His eyes opened. He became more reliably responsive. Over a period of months, members of the research team then tracked the man's abilities during stretches when the current was turned on, and periods when it was off, without knowing when the device was activated.

They found a gradual but consistent improvement in speech and movement when the device was on, and a loss of progress when it was off. The researchers received consent to operate from his parents but said that an ethical framework must be developed to accommodate patients like this, whose mental competency could change by the day. The man now has the device turned on 12 hours a day, and is very much a presence in his room, when he was not before.

"He has regained his personhood, his personal agency," said Dr. Joseph Fins, chief of medical ethics at Cornell, and a study co-author. The patient has amnesia and cannot yet fully represent his interests, Dr. Fins added, "but now he's got interests to represent."

TAGGED: MEDICINE


RELATED CONTENT

Analysis: Why it’s irrational to risk...

Peter Singer - The Scotsman Comments

Analysis: Why it’s irrational to risk women’s lives for the sake of the unborn

Jumping Genes a Cause of Cancer?

Ruth Williams - TheScientist Comments

Double helix showing coplanar alignment of standard base pairs.

A Mathematical Challenge to Obesity

CLAUDIA DREIFUS - New York Times 15 Comments

Carson C. Chow deploys mathematics to solve the everyday problems of real life. As an investigator at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, he tries to figure out why 1 in 3 Americans are obese.

Cocaine decreases activity of a protein...

- - MedicalXpress 27 Comments

Cocaine decreases activity of a protein necessary for normal functioning of the brain's reward system

Neurons Mirror the Diametric Mind

Christopher Badcock, Ph.D -... 3 Comments

Neurons Mirror the Diametric Mind

Schizophrenics amplify neuronal mirroring, autistics reduce it

How thinking about death can lead to a...

- - MedicalXpress 11 Comments

How thinking about death can lead to a good life
Thinking about death can actually be a good thing. An awareness of mortality can improve physical health and help us re-prioritize our goals and values, according to a new analysis of recent scientific studies. Even non-conscious thinking about death – say walking by a cemetery – could prompt positive changes and promote helping others.

MORE

MORE BY BENEDICT CAREY

Psychiatry Giant Sorry for Backing Gay...

Benedict Carey - New York Times 76 Comments

Dr. Robert L. Spitzer, considered by some to be the father of modern psychiatry, recants his study that supported the use of so-called reparative therapy to “cure” homosexuality.

Memory Implant Gives Rats Sharper...

Benedict Carey - The New York Times 31 Comments

Tolerance Over Race Can Spread, Studies...

Benedict Carey 34 Comments

Citizen Enforcers Take Aim

Benedict Carey 27 Comments

Genes Tied to Bad Reactions to...

Benedict Carey 35 Comments

Who's Minding the Mind?

Benedict Carey 14 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment