This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Louisiana's latest creationism bill moves to House floor

Call to Action
If you thought the Dover Trial would rid us of the Creationists and the Discovery Institute, think again. The National Center for Science Education (www.ncseweb.org/) as well as educators across the US are having to spend time, effort and money fighting to save public education. Currently the most critical situation is int he State of Louisiana. Please help fight Senate Bill 733.

Eugenie Scott, Executive Director of NCSE also warns "We anticipate that next fall or spring (depending on the legislative calendar) there will be new bills proposed in several states (we already know of bills being proposed in OK, NM, and TX, and anticipate IN and some other states.) If the LA bill passes, it will encourage creationists in other states to try the model legislation (originally from an Alabama bill, but tweaked by the Discovery Institute -- http://www.academicfreedompetition.com/freedom.php )"

Reposted from the National Center for Science Education:
http://www.ncseweb.org/resources/news/2008/LA/66_louisianas_latest_creationism_5_23_2008.asp
go to original article for relevant links

On May 21, 2008, Senate Bill 733, the so-called Louisiana Science Education Act, was unanimously passed by the Louisiana House Education Committee. Before passage, the bill was amended slightly from the form which passed the Senate on April 29, 2008, as previously reported by NCSE. It now moves to the full House.

The Associated Press reports (May 21, 2008) that, over the course of a hearing that lasted close to three hours, "Science teachers called Senate Bill 733 a veiled attempt to add religion to science classes." The bill singles evolution out from other scientific theories, and states that a teacher "may use supplemental textbooks and other instructional materials to help students understand, analyze, critique, and review scientific theories in an objective manner."

In the House hearing, some critics pointed out that the bill's stated goals are already covered by policies set by the state's Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. The Baton Rouge Advocate reports Tammy Wood, a science teacher from the Zachary, Louisiana school district, told the committee: "There is absolutely no need for this bill," and added "I am begging you here today to kill this bill."

After the bill passed the state Senate, Alan Leshner, CEO of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, wrote to the New Orleans Times-Picayune (May 6, 2008), and echoed the same sentiments. "Proponents offer deceptive arguments about encouraging students to think critically," he observed. "But Louisiana's education standards already do that. The real intent is to introduce classroom materials that raise misleading objections to the well-documented science of evolution and offer a religious idea called intelligent design as a supposed alternative. That would unleash an assault against scientific integrity, leaving students confused about science and unprepared to excel in a modern workforce."

While bill sponsor Senator Ben Nevers (D-Bogalusa) insisted to the AP on May 21 that "I plainly state in this bill that no religion will be taught," he previously told the Hammond Daily Star (April 6, 2008) that the bill was drafted by a group which "believe[s] that scientific data related to creationism should be discussed." Similarly, bill supporter David Tate, a member of the Livingston Parish School Board, told the New Orleans Times-Picayune (April 18, 2008), "I believe that both sides -- the creationism side and the evolution side -- should be presented and let students decide what they believe," adding that the bill is needed because "teachers are scared to talk about" creationism.

At the hearing in the House committee, Caroline Crocker, CEO of the Intelligent Design and Evolution Awareness (IDEA) Center, "said Darwinian evolution is outdated and doesn't explain new findings in science. She also said she had been persecuted in the academic world because of her views," according to the AP. NCSE examined her claims of persecution in our response to her appearance in Ben Stein's antievolution movie, Expelled.

Opponents cited these statements to argue that the bill would open classrooms to creationism. House Education Committee Chairman Don Trahan (R-Lafayette) responded by proposing an amendment which the AP explains "would give the state Board of Elementary and Secondary Education the ability to prohibit introduction of materials."

NCSE board member Barbara Forrest told the committee that even the amended version was too broadly written. "Anything could get into the classroom," the AP reports her telling the committee.

That prospect worries the Baton Rouge Advocate's editorial board, which wrote (May 21, 2008) that the bill will "provide a full-time living for dozens of lawyers in the American Civil Liberties Union. They will have a field day suing taxpayer-funded schools as groups use Nevers' language to push Bible-based texts in the schools. That's unconstitutional, and we can see the taxpayer paying -- and paying, and paying -- for this policy in the future."


May 23, 2008

Associated Press Report:
http://www.shreveporttimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080521/NEWS01/80521030

The Baton Roughe Advocate:
http://www.2theadvocate.com/news/19139834.html

The New Orleans Times-Picayune:
http://www.nola.com/news/index.ssf/2008/04/panel_oks_bill_on_science_text.html

For more information on this bill go to:
http://lasciencecoalition.org/

TAGGED: CREATIONISM, EDUCATION, LAW, RELIGION


RELATED CONTENT

No fence to sit on

David Catchpoole - Creation... Comments

Neutrality is impossible in the creation/evolution debate

Stop Governor Jindal’s Creationist...

Zack Kopplin - Repealing the... Comments

Stop Governor Jindal’s Creationist Voucher Program Before Governor Romney Takes it Nationwide

Ending the Wedge

Adam Rutherford - New Humanist Comments

A recognised creationist tactic involves scoring minor victories against the teaching of evolution, and recent controversies over free schools and the Giant’s Causeway suggest it is succeeding in the UK. It’s time the strategy was exposed

Free School due to open in September...

- - British Humanist Association Comments

Free School due to open in September 2012 will ‘teach creation as a scientific theory’

Richard Dawkins on Radio Ulster -...

- - UTV Comments

An exhibit in the new Giants' Causeway Visitors' Centre acknowledges the creationist view of how the world-famous stones were formed.

What's the Matter With Creationism?

Katha Pollitt - The Nation Comments

The worst thing about the recent Gallup poll on evolution is that the proportion of college graduates who are creationists is exactly the same as for the general public.

MORE

MORE BY NATIONAL CENTER FOR SCIENCE EDUCATION

God, Darwin or...Both?

National Center for Science Education... 21 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment