Richard Dawkins replies to Libby Purves
By RICHARD DAWKINS, TIMES ONLINE
Added: Thu, 07 Aug 2008 23:00:00 UTC
Professor Richard Dawkins on his television programme about Charles Darwin, evolution and atheism
Yesterday, Libby Purves wrote about Professor Richard Dawkins' television series about Charles Darwin. Richard Dawkins writes in reply:
Sir, In her article about episode 1 of my television documentary, The Genius of Charles Darwin, Libby Purves says that I offered the children a choice "as stark as any bonkers tin-hut preacher from the Quivering Brethren shouting: 'Repent or burn!' Evolution or God — take your choice, kid! The moment one of them found an ammonite on the beach, Professor Dawkins demanded instant atheism" (Opinion, August 7).
That is unjust, to the point of outright mendacity, and an insult to any professional educator. It was the creation-indoctrinated children themselves who made the leap: "Evolution = atheism". I was scrupulously careful not to make that connection in the presence of the children, although I have made it elsewhere, spelling out the nuanced argument in The God Delusion.
She goes on to say, "OK, he is provoked, as we all are, by nutters. But most believers are not creationists." I expect it's true that the few believers Libby Purves meets over canapés are not creationists. But "most believers"? Most believers in Bradford? The Scottish Highlands? Pakistan? Indonesia? The Arab world? South America? Indeed, North America? Polls suggest that more than 40 per cent of the British population are creationists. For the subset who call themselves believers, the figure must be considerably more than 50 per cent. Please don't say "most people", when what you really mean is Islington and Hampstead Garden Suburb.
Leave your comment here:
- - RichardDawkins.net 133 Comments
Sky News at 3.30 pm GMT
BBC Newsnight beginning at 10.30 pm GMT.
Matthew Holehouse - The Telegraph 98 Comments
An ITV spokesman said: “We often make changes to programmes before transmission and on this occasion we felt that the song didn’t quite work editorially.”
- - - 108 Comments
Richard Dawkins on Sky News, today (Sat 17 Dec), 1.30 pm GMT, in response to David Cameron's claim that Britain is a Christian country.