This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

The Upside of Feeling Down

http://www.newsweek.com/id/220858

Happiness has had a tough time of it lately. The backlash against the seemingly endless stream of books about the subject (Amazon returned 426,789 titles when I used that search term, including one that calls happiness "life's most important skill") had already set in last year. At the time, I pointed out that "among people with late-stage illnesses, those with the greatest sense of well-being were more likely to die in any given period of time than the mildly content were. Being 'up' all the time can cause you to play down very real threats," and channeled the arguments of scholars who lamented the medicalization of the normal human emotion of sadness.

These and other critiques of happiness and the happiness industry, however, came mostly from psychologists, philosophers, and sociologists who are concerned about the effect of a message that says modest levels of well-being aren't enough, and that we all practically have a duty to be really, really happy—and that what was once considered normal sadness is something to be smothered, even shunned. I was therefore interested to see a new scientific paper taking a more brain-based perspective. (My thanks to The Psych Student blog for drawing my attention to it.)

Writing in the journal Psychological Review, postdoctoral fellow Paul Andrews of Virginia Commonwealth University and psychiatrist J. Anderson Thomson Jr. of the University of Virginia present research suggesting that depression is present in the species, and in individuals, for a purpose, and we're playing with fire if we try to eradicate it. In evolution-speak, depression is an "adaptation," they argue. That is, it evolved because it made individuals who experienced it fitter, under natural selection, than individuals who did not experience it. Andrews and Thomson—who is best known for research on the psychology of religious belief, and who has also studied whether antidepressants threaten love and fidelity—offer as evidence the presence of a molecule in the brain called the 5HT1A receptor. This serves as a docking port for the neurochemical serotonin, which the Prozac/Zoloft/Paxil class of antidepressants targets. Human brains are not the only ones with the 5HT1A receptor. Rats also have it.
...
Continue reading
http://www.newsweek.com/id/220858

TAGGED: EVOLUTION, PSYCHIATRY, PSYCHOLOGY


RELATED CONTENT

Depression Defies the Rush to Find an...

Richard A. Friedman, M.D. - The New... 32 Comments

Depression Defies the Rush to Find an Evolutionary Upside

Hippocampus plays bigger memory role...

- - Med 2 Comments

Human memory has historically defied precise scientific description, its biological functions broadly but imperfectly defined in psychological terms. In a pair of papers published in the November 2 issue of The Journal of Neuroscience, researchers at the University of California, San Diego report a new methodology that more deeply parses how and where certain types of memories are processed in the brain, and challenges earlier assumptions about the role of the hippocampus.

More clues in the genetics of...

David Cyranoski - naturenews 1 Comments

Tissue-bank shortage: Brain child

Alison Abbott - naturenews 0 Comments

Brain Energy

Emily Deans - Psychology Today 2 Comments

The woman misdiagnosed with...

- - Research Digest - Blogging on... 20 Comments

MORE

MORE BY SHARON BEGLEY

New DNA reader to bring promise

Sharon Begley - Reuters 10 Comments


Ion Torrent CEO and chairman Jonathan Rothberg
holds a semiconductor sequencing chip that will
be used in the new Proton semi-conductor based
genome sequencing machine in Guilford,
Connecticut, January 5, 2012.
Credit: Reuters/Michelle McLoughlin

(Un)wired For God

Sharon Begley - Newsweek 32 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment