This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Any fool can make a rule and any fool will mind it

Original link

Andrew Brown, the Guardian’s Fool in Residence, has written another painfully ridiculous excuse for a column: “Richard Dawkins’s backwards logic over atheist schooling,” subtitled “Richard Dawkins’s belief that any properly brought up child will naturally be an atheist leads him into absurdity.”

Some choice bits from The Fool:

But “evidence”, tends to be defined backwards in these polemics – in other words, he starts from the axiom that there is no evidence whatsoever for the existence of God, (implied here in his remark that “Every atheist I know would change their mind in a heartbeat if any evidence appeared in favour of religious belief”) and then find meanings for the term that fit this use. This is of course the same trick as defining faith as belief without evidence and then using this definition as proof that faith is irrational.

Andrew Brown, listen up. Try to follow me here:

  1. There is no evidence whatsoever for the existence of God.
  2. Any intellectually honest atheist indeed would change their position were there any such evidence.
  3. Faith, by definition, is “belief without evidence.” Of course it is “irrational.”

He goes on:

If that sounds unfair, consider the uses of “evidence” in his discussion of education here: “Children should be taught to ask for evidence, to be sceptical, critical, open-minded. If children understand that beliefs should be substantiated with evidence, as opposed to tradition, authority, revelation or faith, they will automatically work out for themselves that they are atheists.” It’s clear here that Dawkins is starting from the definition that “evidence” is what can’t justify a belief in God, whereas “tradition, authority, revelation, and faith” have all been used to justify religious belief, so they must be bad.

  1. Again: there is no evidence whatsoever for the existence of God.
  2. Yes, believing something without evidence is “bad.” Teaching a child that tradition, authority, and revelation are good reasons for believing something to be true is cruel. Cruel. It stunts their intellectual and emotional growth. It discourages them from asking questions and thinking critically. It makes them into gullible little creatures, many of whom never develop the ability to think for themselves. It deprives them.

And more:
... Continue reading

TAGGED: ATHEISM, COMMENTARY, RELIGION


RELATED CONTENT

Science journalism through the looking...

Chris Chambers and Petroc Sumner -... Comments

Science has an uneasy relationship with journalism, so what can be done by both sides to improve coverage

In defence of obscure words

Will Self - BBC News Magazine 100 Comments

We chase "fast culture" at our peril - unusual words and difficult art are good for us, says Will Self.

Your Brain on Fiction

Annie Murphy Paul - New York Times 26 Comments

New support for the value of fiction is arriving from an unexpected quarter: neuroscience.

The spectre of militant secularism

Nick Cohen - The Spectator 40 Comments

If you turn on the news tonight and hear of a bomber slaughtering civilians anywhere from Nigeria to the London Underground, I can reassure you of one point: the bombers will not be readers of Richard Dawkins.

A brutal price still paid for daring to...

Amol Rajan - The Independent 39 Comments

Their assault illustrates the extent to which defenders of religion still dominate our press, the brutal retaliation exacted on clever opponents of faith and the incorrigible stupidity of Sayeeda Warsi's claim about "militant secularism" last week.

The Sins of the Fathers [Also in Polish]

Richard Dawkins - RichardDawkins.net 341 Comments

I can’t help wondering at the quality of journalism which sees a scoop in attacking a man for what his five-greats grandfather did.

MORE

MORE BY MIRANDA CELESTE HALE

A worthless and dangerous report

Miranda Celeste Hale -... 34 Comments

A dirty little girl, her head hanging...

Miranda Celeste Hale - Ex-catholic... 71 Comments

Transubstantiation

Miranda Celeste Hale - ex-catholic... 93 Comments

Two Catholic Posts on EWL

Miranda Celeste Hale - Exquisite With... 16 Comments

If anyone's a real Christian,...

Miranda Celeste Hale - exquisite with... 318 Comments

Rabbit is the question

Miranda Celeste Hale - exquisite with... 131 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment