This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Thank goodness for Christopher Hitchens!

Thanks to Catalin for the link

Could it be that some of the Catholics praying for Christopher Hitchens have heard about the Harvard study of prayer and are hoping to provide some further evidence of its one surprising result? In the 2006 study organized by Herbert Benson of Harvard Medical School, the only large-scale and well-controlled scientific examination of the efficaciousness of prayers for hospital patients, there were no statistically significant effects--except for a small negative effect, in which people who knew they were being prayed for did, on average, somewhat worse than the others! So praying for Hitch might be counterproductive. Why might this curious effect exist?

Sports fans and opera buffs know that their sheer presence in the audience, swelling the number of those paying attention, has an effect on the performers--so long as the performers know they are there. Enthusiastic applause boosts moral--and usually that in turn boosts performance, but occasionally, it can lead to "choking" (almost literally in the case of opera singers). People can be unnerved by too much attention, too many anxious people trying to beam too much goodwill by the sheer force of their eagerness. But I suspect that if careful studies have been done of fan "prayer" --they may have, but if so, I don't know them--the net average effect will have been shown to be positive: when people are "rooting for you," you do better. Certainly that is what athletes and opera singers believe; they love a large following. And I'm happy to assume that this is what Catholics believe as well.

When I was in a similar medical crisis four years ago, I wrote a piece ["Thank Goodness!"] about my gratitude to the doctors (not to God) for saving my life, and said I was forgiving those friends of mine who had the courage to tell me that they were praying for me. I resisted the temptation to respond "Thanks, I appreciate it, but did you also sacrifice a goat?"


... continue reading

TAGGED: CHRISTOPHER HITCHENS, COMMENTARY, RELIGION


RELATED CONTENT

Richard Dawkins & Lawrence Krauss...

- - YouTube - Atheist Foundation 43 Comments

Richard Dawkins & Lawrence Krauss Tribute to Christopher Hitchens - 2012 Global Atheist Convention

Orwell prize: Christopher Hitchens...

John Dugdale - The Guardian 4 Comments

Orwell prize: Christopher Hitchens honoured with memorial award

Heaven Can Wait - Was I wrong about the...

Christopher Hitchens, as told to Art... 49 Comments


Heaven Can Wait - Was I wrong about the afterlife? No.

Appeal to Freethinkers to Fight Cancer

- - YouTube - ScottBurdickArt 14 Comments


Appeal to Freethinkers to Fight Cancer

Stephen Fry & friends on the life,...

- - YouTube - iqsquared 33 Comments

Stephen Fry & friends on the life, loves and hates of Christopher Hitchens - IQ2 talks

In Defense of Richard Dawkins

Christopher Hitchens - Free Inquiry 52 Comments

Why should he sit still and see a valued and precious discipline being insulted, even threatened with not being taught?

MORE

MORE BY DANIEL C. DENNETT

Skeptical clergy a silent majority?

Daniel C. Dennett - The Washington... 40 Comments

Problem of evil and religion's...

Daniel C. Dennett - The Washington... 73 Comments

Religious no longer a protected class

Daniel C. Dennett - The Washington... 77 Comments

Response to Orr

Daniel C. Dennett 14 Comments

The God Delusion

Daniel C. Dennett 117 Comments

Not Yet The Majority But No Longer...

Daniel C. Dennett 73 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment