This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

The religious excuse for barbarity

Why are we sitting silently while our treatment of many of our animals regresses to the standard of the sixth century?

If you are engaged in an act of cruelty, there is an easy, effective way to silence your critics and snatch some space to carry on. Tell us all that your religion requires you to do it, and you are "offended" by any critical response. Erect an electric wire fence around your nastiest actions and call it "respect".

There's a good example of this religious modus operandi playing out on a dinner table near you – and this week, we found out it is becoming more and more common. In Britain, it is a crime to kill a conscious cow or sheep or chicken for meat by slashing its throat without numbing it first. The reasons are obvious. If you don't numb an animal, it screams as you hack through its skin, muscle, trachea, oesophagus, carotid arteries, jugular veins and major nerve trunks, and then it remains conscious as it slowly drowns in its own blood – a process that can take up to six minutes. So we insist that an animal is stunned before its throat is slashed, to ensure it is deeply unconscious. There isn't much humanity in our factory farming system, but this is – at least – a tiny sliver of it, at the end.

But there is a loophole in the law. You are allowed to skip all this and slash the throats of un-numbed, screaming animals if you say God told you to. If you are Muslim, you call it "halal", and if you are Jewish you call it "kosher". Back in the Bronze Age, or the deserts of sixth-century Arabia, it was sensible to act this way. You needed to know your meat was fresh and the animal was not sick, so you made sure it was alive and alert when you killed it. As Woody Allen once said, it wasn't so much a commandment as "advice on how to eat out safely in Jerusalem". But we have much better ways of making sure meat is fresh and healthy now. Yet for many religious people it has hardened into a dogma, to be followed simply because it was laid down in their "holy" texts long ago by "God".

Of course, they claim that this practice isn't cruel at all. Henry Grunwald, chairman of the main body overseeing the certification of kosher meat, Shechita UK, says that when you slash an animal's throat "there is an instant drop in blood pressure in the brain. The animal is dead." Similarly, Raghib Ali, of the Oxford Islam and Muslim Awareness Project, says: "It's not cruel, it is better for the animal."

... Read more

TAGGED: ISLAM


RELATED CONTENT

Pakistani girl accused of Qur'an...

Jon Boone - The Guardian Comments

Tensions rise between Muslim and Christian communities amid claims that 11-year-old desecrated text

Update - NewStatesman article -...

AFP - Yahoo News Comments

A Pakistani-born couple were jailed for life by a British court Friday for murdering their "westernised" teenage daughter in an apparent honour killing.

British Police: You did the Islamic...

Maryam Namazie - - Comments

British Police: You did the Islamic morality police proud

Jihadists’ Fierce Justice Drives...

Adam Nossiter - The New York Times Comments

The vast desert expanse of northern Mali has become a magnet for Islamic extremists.

Letter to Trevor Phillips, Chair of...

- - Maryam Namazie Comments

Letter to Trevor Phillips, Chair of Equality and Human Rights Commission

The courage to think for themselves

Maryam Namazie - Council of... Comments

Over one hundred people joined the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain’s hugely successful 5th anniversary celebration luncheon

MORE

MORE BY JOHANN HARI

Free speech and religious fundamentalism

Johann Hari - The Independent 57 Comments

Johann Hari interviews PZ Myers

Johann Hari - Independent podcast 36 Comments

Can we talk about Muslim homophobia now?

Johann Hari - Attitude 128 Comments

The Valley of Taboos

Johann Hari - Slate 34 Comments

[Update - additional video link] Johann...

Johann Hari - YouTube - frusciante001 37 Comments

Johann Hari on Tony Livesey

Johann Hari - BBC Radio 5 21 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment