This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Cynicism by the Book

Hamid Karzai's despicable response to the Quran burning in Florida.

Heinrich Heine's famous observation about book burning—that where books are burned, people also will be—was actually first made about the torching of the Quran. The Spanish Inquisition used to delight in putting heretical works "on trial," and zealously convicted the Muslim holy book before feeding it to the flames in what is one of Christianity's oldest traditions. (After all, it extends to the burning of unauthorized translations of the Holy Bible, too.) Heine's 1821 play Almansor contains a character who observes that humans will next be burned, and the later incineration of Heine's own writings by the Nazis, with its prefiguration of the Holocaust, has made the quotation an imperishable one.

The connection, however, is not always so neat. The moronic pastor who burned the Quran after a mock trial would probably refrain from setting fire to human beings. While in Afghanistan, where Islam already makes huge numbers of books unavailable and The Satanic Verses and the Danish flag must be in short supply, the news of book burning somewhere else is enough in itself to cause the random incineration of people.

How dispiriting to see, once again, the footage of theocratic rage in Kandahar and Mazar-i-Sharif. The same old dreary formula: self-righteous frenzy married to a neurotic need to take offense; the easy resort to indiscriminate violence and cruelty; the promulgation of makeshift fatwas by mullahs on the make; those writhing mustaches framing crude slogans of piety and hatred, and yelling for death as if on first-name terms with the Almighty. The spilling of blood and the spoliation of property—all for nothing, and ostensibly "provoked" by the corny, brainless antics of a devout American nonentity, notice of whose mere existence is beneath the dignity of any thinking person.
Read more

TAGGED: CHRISTOPHER HITCHENS, COMMENTARY


RELATED CONTENT

Richard Dawkins & Lawrence Krauss...

- - YouTube - Atheist Foundation 43 Comments

Richard Dawkins & Lawrence Krauss Tribute to Christopher Hitchens - 2012 Global Atheist Convention

Orwell prize: Christopher Hitchens...

John Dugdale - The Guardian 4 Comments

Orwell prize: Christopher Hitchens honoured with memorial award

Heaven Can Wait - Was I wrong about the...

Christopher Hitchens, as told to Art... 49 Comments


Heaven Can Wait - Was I wrong about the afterlife? No.

Appeal to Freethinkers to Fight Cancer

- - YouTube - ScottBurdickArt 14 Comments


Appeal to Freethinkers to Fight Cancer

Stephen Fry & friends on the life,...

- - YouTube - iqsquared 33 Comments

Stephen Fry & friends on the life, loves and hates of Christopher Hitchens - IQ2 talks

In Defense of Richard Dawkins

Christopher Hitchens - Free Inquiry 52 Comments

Why should he sit still and see a valued and precious discipline being insulted, even threatened with not being taught?

MORE

MORE BY CHRISTOPHER HITCHENS

Arguably: Essays by Christopher Hitchens

Christopher HItchens - - 32 Comments

Unspoken Truths

Christopher HItchens - Vanity Fair 49 Comments

Until cancer attacked his vocal cords, the author didn’t fully appreciate what was meant by “a writer’s voice,” or the essential link between speech and prose. As a man who loved to talk, he turns to the masters of such conversation, both in history and in his own circle.

Reflections on Political Violence

Christopher HItchens - Slate 52 Comments

The Blair Hitch Project

Christopher HItchens - Vanity Fair 63 Comments

MORE

Comments

Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment