This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Secularism, priorities, Islam, and Waleed Aly

What follows here after some introductory paragraphs repeats almost verbatim a post that I published over on my personal blog back in 2007. Now, my thinking has moved on a little bit since then, and you will see a slightly different formulation and emphasis in Freedom of Religion and the Secular State: I am less enthusiastic, for example, about the word “religionist” than I once was, and I would no longer be so quick to dismiss the word “Islamophobia” as merely stupid (I discuss the issue of “Islamophobia” in the book). But what I have to say in the 2007 post, responding to some views of Australian moderate/liberal (I guess) Muslim author Waleed Aly, still strikes me as about right and as fairly clear. Aly questions why we should want a separation of church (or mosque) and state, and is sceptical that there is any basis for such a principle in modern democracies. Should we agree with him?

In developing his views, Aly uses arguments that should, I think, cause us concern. But reflection on this also raises more general questions about the priorities and motivations of secularists. In researching Freedom of Religion and the Secular State, I was struck by how many supporters of a church/state separation do not share my suspicion of using state power to enforce religious morality. For me, this is a priority – indeed, a higher priority than some other concerns that perhaps are clearer examples of church/state entanglement but are less oppressive (I have in mind, for example, the established churches of Europe). For some of us, at least, the greatest fear in contemporary circumstances is not that we will be required to put up with or take part in religious ceremonies and the like; rather, it is that politicians who are able to command electoral support will bring their religions’ doctrines, particularly those doctrines relating to canons of conduct, to the table of ordinary politics, and attempt to impose them on an unwilling minority.

Read more



Pakistani girl accused of Qur'an...

Jon Boone - The Guardian Comments

Tensions rise between Muslim and Christian communities amid claims that 11-year-old desecrated text

Update - NewStatesman article -...

AFP - Yahoo News Comments

A Pakistani-born couple were jailed for life by a British court Friday for murdering their "westernised" teenage daughter in an apparent honour killing.

British Police: You did the Islamic...

Maryam Namazie - - Comments

British Police: You did the Islamic morality police proud

Jihadists’ Fierce Justice Drives...

Adam Nossiter - The New York Times Comments

The vast desert expanse of northern Mali has become a magnet for Islamic extremists.

Letter to Trevor Phillips, Chair of...

- - Maryam Namazie Comments

Letter to Trevor Phillips, Chair of Equality and Human Rights Commission

The courage to think for themselves

Maryam Namazie - Council of... Comments

Over one hundred people joined the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain’s hugely successful 5th anniversary celebration luncheon



Islam, racists, and legitimate debate

Russell Blackford - Talking Philosophy Comments

Islam, racists, and legitimate debate

Russel Blackford reviews Attack of the...

Russell Blackford - Metamagician and... 24 Comments

Currently reading - Attack of the Theocrats by Sean Faircloth

Religious freedom and religious...

Russell Blackford - Talking Philosophy 17 Comments

I enjoyed reading Mike LaBossiere’s post entitled “Church & State: Immaculate Contraception”, but I can’t resist the impulse to add a post of my own – perhaps because I lack free will in the matter, but mainly because I devote an entire chapter of Freedom of Religion and the Secular State to this sort of issue (so it is kind of on my mind), and certainly because it has become even more topical than usual.

Freedom of Religion and The Secular...

Russell Blackford - Embiggen Books -... 12 Comments

More rubbish about "shrill" atheists -...

Russell Blackford - Metamagician and... 90 Comments

Freedom of Religion and the Secular...

Russell Blackford - - 20 Comments



Comment RSS Feed

Please sign in or register to comment