What-If and What-Is: The Role of Speculation in Science
By JAMES GORMAN - NEW YORK TIMES
Added: Fri, 25 May 2012 19:29:22 UTC
Woody Allen once said that when you do comedy, you sit at the children’s table. The same might be said of speculation in science.
And yet speculation is an essential part of science. So how does it fit in? Two recent publications, both about the misty depths of canine and human history, suggest some answers. In one, an international team of scientists concludes that we really don’t know when and where dogs were domesticated. Greger Larson of the University of Durham, in England, the first of 20 authors of that report, said of dog DNA, “it’s a mess.”
In the other, Pat Shipman, an independent scientist and writer suggests that dogs may have helped modern humans push the Neanderthals out of existence and might even have helped shape human evolution.
Is one right and the other wrong? Are both efforts science — one a data-heavy reality check and the other freewheeling speculation? The research reported by Dr. Larson and his colleagues in The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences is solid science, easily judged by peers, at any rate. The essay by Dr. Shipman is not meant to come to any conclusion but to prompt thought and more research. It, too, will be judged by other scientists, and read by many nonscientists.
But how is one to judge the value of speculation? There are a few obvious ways. The questions readers ought to ask when confronting a “what-if “as opposed to “what-is” article are: Does the writer make it clear what is known, what is probable, and what is merely possible?
Dr. Shipman was careful to make these distinctions in her essay in American Scientist, and in an interview, when I asked her to walk me through her argument.
Dan Gilgoff - CNN Comments
“A lot of millennials who are coming of age have found that the Internet is a fantastic place to talk about their doubt,” says Jesse Galef, communications director for the Secular Student Alliance.
First Aid Kit - YouTube -... Comments
First Aid Kit - Hard Believer
-- - The Telegraph Comments
Hotel boss Wayne Bartholomew in unrepentant about his new choice of bedside reading for his guests despite an outcry from church authorities.
-- - CNN Comments
Sally Ride, the first American woman to fly in space, died Monday after a 17-month battle with pancreatic cancer, her company said. She was 61.
Tracie Powell - Poynter Comments
rbutr is an application which allows people to follow inter-website debates and easily find and create counter arguments to pages they are viewing.
AP - CBC News Comments
The pioneering work of Abdus Salam, Pakistan's only Nobel laureate, helped lead to the apparent discovery of the subatomic Higgs boson, or "God particle," last week, but the late physicist is no hero at home, where his name has been stricken from school textbooks.
MORE BY JAMES GORMAN
James Gorman - The New York Times 35 Comments
Before Wolves May Be Hunted, Science, Faith and Politics Clash