This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

New Studies Say No, Life Can't Live on Arsenic Alone


This is a transmission electron micrograph of a strain of proteobacteria that has been exposed to arsenic in place of phosphorus. The bacteria grew much larger with the addition of arsenic and the subtraction of phosphorus, and scientists think the internal vacuole-like structures shown in this image may be responsible for the larger size. Courtesy Science/AAAS

The fundamental backbone of life is unbending, according to two new studies — a plucky bacterium from a California lake cannot substitute a poisonous substance for phosphorus after all. The results address the question of whether GFAJ-1, as the bacterium is known, is “weird life” with implications for astrobiology. According to these new studies, the answer may be no after all.

Two new studies appearing today attempted to recreate a controversial December 2010 study by Felisa Wolfe-Simon and others, who fed the bacteria a cocktail of arsenic and deprived it of phosphorus. GFAJ-1 is found in California’s Mono Lake, which contains arsenic-rich sediments. All of life uses six elements: oxygen, carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, phosphorus and sulfur. Arsenic is chemically similar to phosphorus, but it’s toxic. Wolfe-Simon’s results indicated that at least one form of life could buck this trend and survive using arsenic.

Today in Science, Tobias Erb and colleagues at the Institute of Microbiology at ETH Zurich show that it can indeed grow under high-arsenate and low-phosphate conditions, but it needs at least a little bit of phosphate to grow at all. In Wolfe-Simon’s original paper, the authors noted the presence of a small amount of phosphorus, but concluded it was too little to sustain the organisms. This is incorrect, according to Erb et al. The small amounts of phosphorus were indeed enough to keep the bacteria alive.

The Swiss team also found some arsenate-based compounds in the growth medium, but they determined that these formed abiotically. The small amount of arsenate metabolites that GFAJ-1 formed were negligible for sustaining life, they say.

“The new research shows that GFAJ-1 does not break the long-held rules of life, contrary to how Wolfe-Simon had interpreted her group’s data,” says a statement from Science, which took flak for publishing the controversial paper in a firestorm of controversy. The journal later published eight technical comments scrutinizing Wolfe-Simon’s research methods.

For her part, Wolfe-Simon said in an email that the very small amounts of arsenate metabolites may help the organisms survive in environments with lots of arsenic.

"Key questions are, how do these cells thrive in lethal concentrations of arsenic? And where does the arsenic go?" she said.

Read more


Rread this article on the new RDF beta site

TAGGED: BIOLOGY


RELATED CONTENT

Bonobo makes stone tools like early...

Hannah Krakauer - New Scientist Comments

Kanzi the bonobo is able to create and use stone tools

Scientists Discover Previously Unknown...

- - URMC Comments

Newer Imaging Technique Brings ‘Glymphatic System’ to Light

Grey parrots use reasoning where...

- - The Royal Society Comments

Research suggesting that grey parrots can reason about cause and effect from audio cues alone- a skill that monkeys and dogs lack- is presented in Proceedings of the Royal Society B today.

Why do organisms build tissues they...

- - Science Blog Comments

Why, after millions of years of evolution, do organisms build structures that seemingly serve no purpose?

New flat-faced human species possibly...

Charles Choi - CBS News Comments

Four decades ago, in 1972, the Koobi Fora Research Project discovered the enigmatic fossilized skull known as KNM-ER 1470 which ignited a now long-standing debate about how many different species of early Homos existed.

A New Species Discovered ... On Flickr

Adam Cole - NPR Comments

One day in May of 2011, Shaun Winterton was looking at pictures of bugs on the Internet when something unusual caught his eye. It was a close shot of a green lacewing — an insect he knew well — but on its wing was an unfamiliar network of black lines and a few flecks of blue.

MORE

MORE BY REBECCA BOYLE

"Map of Life" Shows the Location of All...

Rebecca Boyle - PopSci 10 Comments

The Map of Life platform lets you search by species, using either its Latin name or common name, and find out where it is located on the planet. The project sheds light on how little we know about some species. Map of Life Project

Neurons in Bird Brains Encode Earth's...

Rebecca Boyle - PopSci 8 Comments

Pigeons have a reliable internal GPS

Rice Is Genetically Modified to Produce...

Rebecca Boyle - POPSCI 5 Comments

Found: The Particular Brain Fold That...

Rebecca Boyle - PopSci 13 Comments

MORE

Comments

Please Login to RDFRS to Comment

Sign in to RDF

blog comments powered by Disqus