This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Comment

← Jamy Ian Swiss - Skepticism and the Art and Philosophy of Magic

Wosret's Avatar Jump to comment 6 by Wosret

5. Comment #185637 by kraut

considering there is nothing "supernatural" out there, not a hard line to draw.Everything is explainable rationally, but for some (quite a few) phenomena we just haven't found the correct explanation yet.


That is a faith based assertion, that can't even begin to be justified. Without omniscience one cannot possible justify it. It is however a cute sentiment.

Skepticism, in a philosophical sense is universal doubt of unjustified and unsupported assertions. Not just supernatural ones.

Supernatural claims are fundamentally useless, and unfalsifiable/unvarifiable in principle. Because it would require that you have a complete and absolute understanding of nature before you could justifiably say that something was a violation or interuption in natural laws. That is the rational reason for rejecting supernatural explanations. Not because they are impossible, which equally pretends to a complete knowledge and understanding of natural law and the universe.

Wed, 28 May 2008 08:42:00 UTC | #176252