This site is not maintained. Click here for the new website of Richard Dawkins.

Comment

← Dawkins & Krauss Discussion from ASU 4 Feb

nurnord's Avatar Jump to comment 22 by nurnord

          [Comment 17](/videos/644930-krauss-and-dawkins-discuss-something-from-nothing/comments?page=1#comment_917077) by  [Ignorant Amos](/profiles/64713)          :


                 Comment 13 by nurnord> Ok, back to this little exchange - I might expect it to be different as there is an ocean of potential and pressing topics to be discussed within our sphere (our sphere meaning atheism, religion, politics, science etc.) of interest (read - concern ?). I don't think it is beyond reason to anticipate a discussion of these things, but not the very same material when the scope is so much wider. I guess that amounts to criticism, not my aim by any measure, I beg of you...> But that's only because you watched both discussions, the two audiences wouldn't necessarily be privy to that. Would you expect to see a comedian on two dates of a tour present different material on each occasion..... how about a rock band?Anyway, it was a thoroughly enjoyable 2 hours that flew by in a flash.

I don't accept either of those points, the former does not address it and the latter is not a valid comparison.

Mon, 13 Feb 2012 04:25:26 UTC | #917085